During a recent Twitch broadcast by art streamer ato1004fd, in which they created a Genshin Impact art piece live, one viewer allegedly took the in-progress artwork and fed it to an AI generator. The viewer then posted the AI-completed piece and claimed it was their own work.
Recommended Videos
The viewer—who posted to Twitter under the name musaishh before deleting their account—proceeded to say ato1004fd was the one who stole from them, claiming that because the artist posted their work around five to six hours after they uploaded the AI version, the true artist must have worked fast and utilized the AI piece for “reference.”
During a Twitch stream AT (@haruno_intro) had their art stolen.
The thief then finished the sketch by using NovelAI and posted on their Twitter before AT finish it.
Then had the AUDACITY to demand a "proper reference" from them. pic.twitter.com/Twv7oWSMaW
— Genel Jumalon ✈️ PAX Unplugged (@GenelJumalon) October 13, 2022Ato1004fd spent over 11 hours working on this piece on Twitch, while musaishh seemingly took the image early on, ran it through an AI system, and uploaded it long before ato1004fd’s artwork was completed.
Because they tried to take credit and undermine the artist, fans and fellow artists alike took notice and rallied behind ato1004fd. In the end, musaishh deactivated their account and ato1004fd shared their finished artwork of the Raiden Shogun from Genshin Impact.
Although everything worked out in the end, this situation led to many within the artist community rallying for change. The Twitter user who highlighted the details around this issue said they “want to see real change to protect artists.”
I just want to see real change to protect artists. That's all.
I've outlined this before but AI should have been trained on Public Domain models. Artists should be able to opt-out of training data. Copyright material should not be used om training data.
— Genel Jumalon ✈️ PAX Unplugged (@GenelJumalon) October 13, 2022A different artist responded to the situation by stating AI artists aren’t true artists “and will never be unless they draw for real.”
How pathetic you have to be to steal art, put it on a AI program and post it before so you can call THE ARTIST a thief. Learn to draw, “AI artist” aren’t artist and will never be unless they draw for real.
— 사토시🎄☃️ (@satow_tewu) October 13, 2022One Twitter user compared what AI artists do to “tracing and editing” others’ work, explaining that “it’s just mashing up together pre-existed artworks to just to make something ‘new.'”
https://twitter.com/hazurine/status/1577945153121107968?s=20&t=0dfBbDjpgpRckgv23dBX0Q
In response to the situation, many artists who regularly livestream or share work-in-progress versions of their art decided they will likely no longer do so, or will only do so with some sort of giant watermark that may help them prevent theft.
This instance of AI art theft certainly wasn’t the first, nor will it be the last. Days before this event occurred, one Twitter user shared the following tweet that perfectly encapsulates the issues artists are facing from those who claim to be “AI artists.”
"I CREATED this art with an AI! It's mine!"
Could you create it without having fed that machine art you didn't license or own?
"Well. No."
Then you didn't create anything. You stole. You're a thief.
When are we gonna see some actual lawsuits here? Lawyer up!
— Parker Simmons (@parkerrsimmons) October 7, 2022This situation is one that likely occurs on a daily basis and is probably one of the few where the thief actually got caught. AI can certainly be a useful tool but is also ethically problematic due to its ability to help people undermine and blatantly steal artists’ hard work. What this means for the future of art is unknown, but artists undoubtedly will continue to seek some form of protection to help them keep their work safe.
ncG1vNJzZmicn6mytLzOq6usZpOkunC%2F06ucmqWZo7RwusSwqmiZoql6tMDRnpimnaKoeq211aKbZpmWqbKzecCiZJqqpJ7AtXnSrZyapKNitKa60qGgp2WZor2ir9NmoKdloKe8qL7ErKpmr5%2BnuG6tzZ1knZ2dlrulv4ycqZ6cmak%3D